Skip to content

Cataract surgery Gaps vary up to 6-fold, data shows

By Trudie McConnochie Reviewed and updated 19 November 2026

Specialists at some private hospitals are charging Gaps for cataract surgery more than 6 times higher than others, new health fund data shows. 

The Australian Health Funds Council (formerly Private Healthcare Australia) analysed cataract surgery Gaps at 122 private hospitals in 2024-25. At 70 hospitals, the typical Medical Gap paid to surgeons and anaesthetists was $500 or less. At 10 hospitals it was more than $1,750, and at one private hospital in Sydney it was $3,034 – 6 times higher.  

The analysis did not include Hospital Gaps for hospital accommodation and theatre fees. 

The Council’s submission to the federal parliamentary inquiry into medical specialist access and affordability also shows large variations in surgeons’ Gaps for other common procedures: 

Procedure Median Gap  10% of patients paid more than  
Knee replacement $1,080 $5,300 
Hip replacement $1,240 $5,500 
Gall bladder removal $600 $2,410 
Children’s tonsil removal $850 $2,210 

Dr Rachel David, CEO of the Australian Health Funds Council, said the large variation in fees was difficult to justify.  

“Patients should not face dramatically different costs for the same procedure when there is no evidence that higher fees deliver better outcomes,” she said. 

“I worry that some people are taking out loans or raiding their super to pay these sorts of fees because they don’t know there are other surgeons and anaesthetists charging much less.” 

Earlier this week, healthslips.com.au reported that consultation fees for specialists had risen 3 times higher than inflation.  

Learn more about how to avoid high out-of-pocket fees for private hospital procedures. 

Trudie McConnochie
Writer and Researcher

Knowledge is power – that’s the guiding principle behind everything Trudie writes, and it’s a philosophy she brings to her work at healthslips.com.au. By breaking down complex information into easy-to-understand blogs and stories, she aims to empower Australians to make the best choices and an informed decision around private health insurance.

Trudie understands firsthand some of the complexity of private health insurance having moved to Australia from New Zealand and having to navigate a vastly different public healthcare system and health insurance structure.

Trudie holds a Bachelor of Communication Studies (journalism major) from the Auckland University of Technology.

Read more.

We promise

Read more
Compare Every
Insurer

Compare all Australian health insurers and every policy

Unbiased
Comparisons

Compare using independent and comprehensive information

Cheapest Policy
Guaranteed

Compare all Private Health Information Statements, cheapest to most expensive

Free Open
Access

Compare without entering your name, email or phone number

Related Content

advertisement
calculate your health insurance

Policies change monthly, stay informed

Subscribe to stay informed. Insurers regularly update policies, introduce new policies and close policies. Our data is updated monthly.
When you give your contact details, you agree we may email you updated insurer information; let you know about helpful services and offers from healthslips.com.au and its trusted partners; and collect, store and use your information as stated in our Privacy Policy.
Thank you for subscribing!